Tough Cookie (Cookies & Cream Peanut Butter)

(21 reviews) Write a Review
16.00 Ounces
Calculated at Checkout

Chocolate and Vanilla Cream Cookies ground into our signature Peanut Butter!

21 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Favorite PB of All Time

    Posted by Unknown on 18th Aug 2021

    If you haven't tried this yet, do it! I'm a big nut butter enthusiast and this is the best I've had. Sweet and smooth, I can eat this straight out of the jar

  • 5
    The Best!

    Posted by Debbie on 26th Jul 2021

    this is so yummy ... love the crunch in it!!! my fav!

  • 5
    Love this flavor!!

    Posted by Cindy on 17th Feb 2021

    This flavor was a delicious surprise. It pairs perfectly with rice cakes for a sweet treat.

  • 5
    Kookies n Kream

    Posted by Unknown on 28th Oct 2020

    Hard not to eat the whole jar..

  • 5
    Must Love Oreos

    Posted by Jill G on 29th Jul 2020

    Addicting! Lock this one up, or you'll polish off the jar in one sitting. I picked this up at a local farmer's market, and ended up going online and ordering nine more flavors. This stuff is insane. This flavor is one of the best! (

  • 5
    Crunchy and Delicious

    Posted by Grant Hunter on 15th Jul 2018

    Essentially, this is peanut butter and Oreo’s. Simple, but quite possibly the best offering from The Peanut Principle (and that’s saying something). Oil separation is a bit more common with this one, but it mixes very easily. Fantastic with a raspberry spread.

  • 5
    Greatest PB ever to walk this earth

    Posted by CookieDoughMonstah on 27th Jun 2018

    I had high expectations going into my first spoonful but my oh my did it STILL blow my mind. In short- it tastes like a family pack of Oreos blended with peanut butter and how could you go wrong with that? I had to hide it away after eating 6 heaping spoons straight out the jar. This stuff is straight crack and you need it in your life.

  • 4
    Just Like Peanut Butter Oreos

    Posted by Matt on 7th Jun 2018

    Imagine taking peanut butter Oreos, blending them down to a smooth paste, and kicking it up a notch with some peanut principle magic. That's what these are.

  • 5

    Posted by Dirk on 6th Jun 2018

    Loved this so much we ordered it again. on our second 10 jar variety order in the last 4 weeks. Crushed up oreos with a cream taste in PB. What else can you want?