Piece of Cake (Cake Batter Peanut Butter)

(29 reviews) Write a Review
16.00 Ounces
Calculated at Checkout

 Cake Batter Peanut Butter...HELLO!!


29 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 4

    Posted by Heather on 4th Oct 2021

    Very tasty , not like birthday cake, but what ever “really” tastes like birthday cake except for actual cake!? Love the sprinkles and the texture.

  • 5
    Piece of Cake

    Posted by Lori on 11th Jan 2021

    I ran across the Peanut Principle at a local craft fair. My son and I both love this peanut butter! creamy yet not too thick. A subtle birthday cake flavor that does not overpower the peanut butter itself. I've already placed another order! I can't be without this stuff in my pantry. And I love that I'm supporting a family business.

  • 5
    Favorite peanut butter

    Posted by Teresa Pacos on 18th Sep 2020

    I’ve started ordering 2 of these jars at a time. I’ve gone through 6 or 7 jars so far. I just eat it with a spoon or put it on apples. It is SO good. I would definitely recommend if you like sweet. It feels like you’re eating dessert.

  • 5
    Best peanut butter EVER.

    Posted by Teresa on 8th Jun 2020

    This legitimately tastes like birthday cake. I eat it with a spoon and it’s incredible. I would buy 20 million jars of it! I will keep buying cause I go through the jars really fast.

  • 4

    Posted by Khadijah on 3rd Mar 2020

    I’m not a huge fan of peanut butter but I thought if I bought a flavored peanut butter, I could stand it. This flavor is tasty. It does taste similar to actual cake batter. I can taste more of the peanut butter but overall it’s good.

  • 5
    It's Amazing

    Posted by Melissa Martenak on 31st Jan 2020

    If you like sprinkles, you'll like this one! We visited the Adirondack's two years ago, and my daughter is hooked! Being the picky eater she is, we are thankful she is able to get her protein in this way! I always buy in bulk so you get free shipping ;)

  • 5
    Piece of Cake is fabulous

    Posted by Lauren McCoy on 19th Jul 2018

    This was the best peanut butter I've ever had. I finished the jar in three days!! The sprinkles are fabulous surprises. I have already reordered and am going to try two other kinds because this one was so good. Joe is awesome at customer service too! What a wonderful company!

  • 5
    Piece of Cake

    Posted by Camille Pacheco on 18th Jun 2018

    One of the best things i’ve ever tried!

  • 5
    my life has been changed

    Posted by hgunter94@gmail.com on 21st May 2018

    It tastes like funfetti birthday cake but it's **HEALTHY** **WHOLESOME** pb. I want to put it on everything.